MySleepCalc Logo
HomeBlogBest Sleep Trackers 2024: Oura vs. Whoop vs. Apple Watch

Best Sleep Trackers 2024: Oura vs. Whoop vs. Apple Watch

A comprehensive review of the best sleep trackers. Compare Oura, Whoop, and smartwatches to see how they work and find the best device to monitor and improve your sleep quality.

Published on June 25, 2024

In our data-driven world, we track our steps, our calories, and our workouts. So why not track our sleep? The market for sleep trackers has exploded, with devices promising to demystify our nights and provide actionable insights. From rings and wristbands to bedside devices and apps, the options can be overwhelming.

This guide provides a comprehensive review of the best sleep trackers available today. We'll break down how they work, compare the top contenders like the Oura Ring and Whoop, and help you decide if investing in a sleep tracker is the right move for you.

How Do Sleep Trackers Work?

Most modern consumer sleep trackers use a combination of sensors to estimate your sleep patterns. The most common are:

  • Accelerometer: A motion sensor that tracks your movement. The assumption is that you move less when you're in deep sleep and more when you're in light sleep or awake.
  • Photoplethysmography (PPG) Sensor: This is the green light on the back of most wearables. It shines light into your skin to measure blood flow, which allows it to estimate your heart rate and Heart Rate Variability (HRV).
  • Temperature Sensor: More advanced trackers use temperature sensors to monitor changes in your skin temperature throughout the night, which can provide insights into your circadian rhythm and health.

By combining this data, these devices create a "hypnogram"—a graph of your estimated sleep stages (Awake, Light, Deep, REM). While not as accurate as a clinical sleep study (polysomnography), they are excellent tools for tracking trends and understanding your personal sleep patterns.

"What gets measured gets managed. A sleep tracker turns your sleep from an unknown into a known quantity you can actively improve."

The Top Contenders: Ring vs. Band vs. Watch

Best Overall: Oura Ring Gen3

The Oura Ring is a leader in the space for a reason. It's discreet, comfortable to wear, and packed with highly accurate sensors. Its key strength is the "Readiness Score," which analyzes your sleep, HRV, and body temperature to give you a daily assessment of your capacity to perform. It's less focused on workout tracking and more on holistic health and recovery.

Best for: The data-driven individual who wants a comprehensive, passive health monitor without a screen.

Downside: Requires a monthly subscription to access most features.

Best for Athletes: Whoop 4.0

Whoop is a screenless wristband heavily marketed towards athletes and serious fitness enthusiasts. Its core features are the "Strain" and "Recovery" scores. It gives you a daily strain target based on your recovery, helping you optimize your training and avoid overtraining. Its sleep coaching feature is excellent, telling you exactly how much sleep you need each night to achieve your desired performance level the next day.

Best for: Athletes and fitness enthusiasts who want to dial in their training and recovery.

Downside: Subscription-only model; less useful if you're not physically active.

Best Smartwatch: Apple Watch / Samsung Galaxy Watch

If you already own a premium smartwatch, its built-in sleep tracking is a great place to start. While historically less accurate than dedicated devices, recent models from Apple and Samsung have become quite good. They offer detailed sleep stage analysis and integrate seamlessly with their respective health ecosystems.

Best for: The person who wants an all-in-one device and doesn't want to wear or pay for a separate tracker.

Downside: Can be bulky to wear to bed; requires nightly charging.

Is a Sleep Tracker Worth It?

A sleep tracker can be an incredibly powerful tool if used correctly. It's not about obsessing over a "perfect" score each night. Instead, it's about:

  • Building Awareness: Simply seeing the data can make you more mindful of your sleep habits.
  • Identifying Trends: You can see how things like a late-night meal, alcohol, or a stressful day affect your sleep quality.
  • Motivation: Seeing your scores improve can be a powerful motivator to stick with good habits.

Ultimately, a sleep tracker provides the data, but you still have to do the work. Combine the insights from a tracker with the strategies from our MySleepCalc tool and blog to create a comprehensive plan for mastering your sleep.

Frequently Asked Questions